EU funds come at a price

“The European Union is not providing us with support, but rather repayments. Three quarters of the money received was returned before 2010, as Western European companies won public procurement financed by EU subsidies. Currently, Hungarian-owned companies have a shot as well – and of course, many don’t like this,” Csaba Lentner, economics professor, told Magyar Nemzet.

Lentner Csaba: A nyugati cégek extraprofitot termeltek, és a pénzt jobbára el is vitték Forrás: Mirkó István

Left-liberal EU representatives and Hungarian politicians are particularly fond of threatening Hungary with EU funds withdrawals if the Orbán government does not say and do as expected from abroad. We are talking about a lot of money – but it does not come free.

“The European Union is not providing us with support, rather repayments” Csaba Lentner told Magyar Nemzet. The economics professor noted that three decades ago, in the process of the regime change, Hungary gave up the protection of its internal markets. Thus, the country gave up the opportunity to help domestic manufacturers and so, Western European products took over the Hungarian market without paying any customs duties. Without the protection of those fees, domestic producers could no longer compete. In addition, neither the government nor the former central bank provided adequate support to domestic producers. Companies from Western Europe essentially suffocated domestic manufacturers. They acquired the domestic Hungarian market, as well as the eastern markets that were once supplied by famous domestic companies.

“Western companies made windfall profits off of Hungary and they took most of that money away” explained the expert. He reminded that during the regime change, everyone could see that the planned economy had failed as the eastern markets collapsed, so the forced orientation towards the West began.

And it was just a faint promise then that Hungary could eventually be a member of the European Union. After a decade and a half, this did happen, but in the meantime, we had given up the right to shape our independent economic policy.

“From the very beginning, Hungary was expected to apply EU fiscal rules and, to a limited extent, the policies of the central bank. The financial framework through which the Hungarian state supported domestic companies such as those in agriculture had to be dismantled” emphasized the economist.

Moreover, we guaranteed healthcare and training for foreign companies financed by our own forint tax budget. “We handed over the country’s opportunities: foreigners settling here received tax benefits, along with settlement and investment subsidies. Companies from the EU’s developed countries came under optimal conditions and they certainly took advantage of that opportunity” explained Csaba Lentner.

The professor also mentioned that every member state contributes to the EU budget. Developed states give more than what they receive in aid. But an agreement has been reached which Hungary will abide by and the others should as well.

“These countries got everything, which is why I emphasize that it is not support that Hungary receives from the EU, but rather repayments. Three quarters of the money received was also returned before 2010, as Western European companies won public procurement financed by EU subsidies. Currently, Hungarian-owned companies have a shot as well – and of course many don’t like this,” said the expert.

Csaba Lenter also spoke about the fact that the European Union is not a fundamentally economic alliance. It was originally created to keep the centuries-old German French conflicts, that often led to war and inferno, under control. The creation of the European community was intended to stifle the differences between the two countries by establishing mutual economic interests. The economic aspects are therefore secondary; it is not in the interest of developed states that Hungary or Bulgaria for example, be as strong as say, Germany. This does not mean that Hungary has no place in the EU, but it must be said that the EU funds are not gifts. Our country has put a lot into the “common pot” as have the other new member states.

Therefore, the resources from the current EU financial cycle cannot be considered a gift arriving to Hungary free of charge.