Non-Compliance to Entail Immediate Expulsion from Hungary

"Non-Hungarian nationals who fail to cooperate with the authorities could face immediate expulsion," Zoltan Lomnici Jr, legal advisor at Szazadveg Foundation, told Magyar Nemzet, speaking about the government's drafting of a new bill and overhaul of the immigration regulations currently in force. The constitutional lawyer expects that Brussels will formulate a critical and biased position, saying that the content and main direction of the Hungarian legislation is on the wrong track.

2023. 11. 14. 14:36
VéleményhírlevélJobban mondva - heti véleményhírlevél - ahol a hét kiemelt témáihoz fűzött személyes gondolatok összeérnek, részletek itt.

"Non-Hungarian nationals who fail to cooperate with the authorities could face immediate expulsion," Zoltan Lomnici Jr, legal advisor at Szazadveg Foundation, told Magyar Nemzet, speaking about the government's drafting of a new bill and overhaul of the immigration regulations currently in force.

Borítókép: Ifj. Lomnici Zoltán alkotmányjogász (Fotó: MTI/Kovács Attila).
Ifj. Lomnici Zoltán elmondta: a módosítással az érintett személy kiutasítását hatékonyabban és gyorsan lehet majd foganatosítani. Fotó: MTI/Kovács Attila)
The amendment will make it possible to expel the person concerned more efficiently and quickly, Zoltan Lomnici Jr said (Photo: MTI/Attila Kovacs

The new bill will make it clear to all third-country nationals that they can only temporarily stay and work in Hungary in accordance with the purposes, legal entitlements and conditions set by the Hungarian state, and only if the state so decides. In order to protect Hungarian families, vacancies must be filled by drawing on Hungary's workforce reserve and involving Hungarian job seekers and inactive persons.

Expulsion can take place in two steps

According to the government's firm decision of principle

foreign labor can be employed only and exclusively when Hungarian workers are unavailable to fill vacancies.
 

To this end, the strictest possible regulations need to be worked out. In order to safeguard national interests, the cabinet also decided that the law regulating the employment of guest workers in Hungary will not be applied until full regulations are in place. The legal expert pointed out that

the amendment will make it possible to expel the person concerned more efficiently and quickly.

Anyone failing to respect the norms of coexistence will be immediately deported from the county, and this rule will also apply to guest workers from abroad, he added. The termination of illegal stay involves a two-step procedure: first, an expulsion order is issued, which opens a period for voluntary departure, the constitutional lawyer explained.

This is followed, if necessary, by a removal decision, which may entail pre-removal detention and ends with deportation. Under the relevant EU legislation, the expulsion decision may allow a period ranging from  7 to 30 days for voluntary departure, which may be shortened, but may also end with immediate expulsion. The authorities may decide so if there is a risk that the non-EU national staying illegally in a country

  • will flee,
  • has submitted a false application, or 
  • poses a risk to public security/national security.

 In practice, this means immediate expulsion.

No returning of people to torture

The Hungarian practice is in line with international law if those expelled are returned to their home country or to a country which is obliged to readmit them, complying with the non-refoulement principle, the expert explained.

No one shall be expelled or extradited to a state where he or she would be in danger of being subjected to a death penalty, torture or other inhuman treatment or punishment,

he said, adding that if a non-EU national holds a valid residence permit or an equivalent permit issued by another EU country, the person must return to that country immediately if expelled.

Brussels is expected to raise its legislative objections as a matter of priority, and the European Commission will certainly draw on its own practice and that of the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg, which have mostly been extremely liberal so far, Zoltan Lomniczi Jr pointed out. The expert predicts that Brussels will formulate a critical and biased position, saying that the content and main direction of the Hungarian legislation is on the wrong track. However, he noted, a growing number of people in Brussels are now saying that the new regulations on migration should put the focus on deportation.

Cover photo: Illegal immigrants heading to Europe arrive at the port of Lampedusa, southern Italy, on September 18, 2023 (Photo: MTI/EPA/ANSA/Ciro Fusco)

A téma legfrissebb hírei

Tovább az összes cikkhez chevron-right

Ne maradjon le a Magyar Nemzet legjobb írásairól, olvassa őket minden nap!

Címoldalról ajánljuk

Tovább az összes cikkhez chevron-right

Portfóliónk minőségi tartalmat jelent minden olvasó számára. Egyedülálló elérést, országos lefedettséget és változatos megjelenési lehetőséget biztosít. Folyamatosan keressük az új irányokat és fejlődési lehetőségeket. Ez jövőnk záloga.