A Raid Rather Than a Well-Thought-Out Attack, Expert Says

The security policy analyst described to Magyar Nemzet the Ukrainian goals of the military operation in the Kursk region and its military background.

2024. 08. 15. 12:05
Russian President Vladimir Putin chairs a meeting on the situation in the Kursk region at his residence in Novo-Ogaryovo, near Moscow, on August 12, 2024 (Photo: AFP/ Gavriil Grigorov)
VéleményhírlevélJobban mondva - heti véleményhírlevél - ahol a hét kiemelt témáihoz fűzött személyes gondolatok összeérnek, részletek itt.

After thousands of Ukrainian soldiers broke through the Russian border with tanks in the early morning hours of August 6, Ukraine now controls 74 settlements in Russia's Kursk region, Oleksandr Syrsky, the commander-in-chief of Ukraine's armed forces, announced on Tuesday.

According to a Ukrainian military official, Russia has pulled out part of its forces from the territory of Ukraine. The information was recently confirmed to the Wall Street Journal by several US officials.

However, the paper also noted that the Ukrainian leadership may face a serious dilemma as to whether a push for further gains is worth deploying more troops and military equipment, which is badly needed on Ukraine's eastern front, where Kyiv forces are struggling to contain the Russian advance.

The main task of the redeployed forces may be to strengthen the defense in Kursk, but for the time being, even the experts can only speculate as to what the military-political goals of the attack could be.  A US official said late on Tuesday that the goal of Ukraine's Kursk incursion appears to be to force Russia to pull troops out of Ukraine to defend Russian territory against the cross-border assault, the Reuters reported

Balint Somkuti, security policy analyst at the Center for Geopolitics, Mathias Corvinus Collegium (Photo: Szabad Fold/Marton Kallai)

In its dimensions and goal,

said security expert Balin Somkuti when Magyar Nemzet asked how Ukraine's invasion of Russia differs from Russia's invasion of Ukraine. "If this was a military raid, it should have entered phase two by now, but it hasn't," the expert added.

The Ukrainian forces should be able to maintain the pace of the attack if the goal was to take the Kursk nuclear power plant, located 80-100 kilometers from the border. However, since this did not happen, it is safe to say that this was a raid rather than a well-thought-out attack, designed to put the war in Ukraine back on the front page of Western newspapers and to deal a blow to the Russian military and political leadership, which Kyiv did indeed,

the expert pointed out, adding that 

in connection with the fighting in the Kursk area, it is worth looking at the Russian troops deployed to repel the offensive. These are so-called "fire response" units, units on constant alert, the Chechen Akhmat fighters, there is talk of a marine brigade and other special forces such as the Spetsnaz or the Wagner Group.

"Moscow must be able to deploy similar forces to successfully stop this attack, which means that we can talk about a few thousand troops, but certainly not tens of thousands," said Balint Somkuti. "Taking into account the extent of the offensive, this area of about fifty by twenty kilometers, there are one or two brigades fighting on the Ukrainian side. And since the second stage did not come, we can assume that this was the total force that was mobilized for this operation," the expert added. 

Regarding the foreign Ukrainian mercenaries reported in the region, Balint Somkuti said that throughout history, mercenaries have traditionally been deployed in high-risk places, and this can  be observed now on part of Ukraine.

Russian President Vladimir Putin chairs a meeting on the situation in the Kursk region (Photo: AFP/Gavriil Grigorov) 

The armed provocation of the Kyiv leadership on the Russia-Ukraine border aims to improve Ukraine's position in future negotiations, but it is pointless to negotiate with a government that attacks civilians, Russian President Vladimir Putin  pointed out earlier this week.

At the same time, increased security measures have been introduced in Moscow with daily reserves created from among the members of the special regiments and the Russian guard, the Ukrainian Korrespondent  reported. Security has also been tightened around the Kremlin and in central locations.

Cover photo: Russian President Vladimir Putin (Photo: AFP/Gavriil Grigorov)

 

A téma legfrissebb hírei

Tovább az összes cikkhez chevron-right

Ne maradjon le a Magyar Nemzet legjobb írásairól, olvassa őket minden nap!

Google News
A legfrissebb hírekért kövess minket az Magyar Nemzet Google News oldalán is!

Címoldalról ajánljuk

Tovább az összes cikkhez chevron-right

Portfóliónk minőségi tartalmat jelent minden olvasó számára. Egyedülálló elérést, országos lefedettséget és változatos megjelenési lehetőséget biztosít. Folyamatosan keressük az új irányokat és fejlődési lehetőségeket. Ez jövőnk záloga.